Rogers, telecom execs to meet with industry minister after outage
Ottawa is demanding that Canada’s telecom giants reach a formal agreement within 60 days to provide mutual assistance should an outage on the scale of the one that hit Rogers Communications Inc.’s wireless and internet services on Friday repeat itself.
On a conference call with reporters Monday afternoon, Industry Minister François-Philippe Champagne said the proposal would ensure that the country be “better prepared if anything similar would happen in Canada,” and include co-operation on emergency roaming as well as communications protocols to better inform the public and authorities.
Champagne, who met with telecom executives Monday afternoon, added that the CRTC will do a fully inquiry into root cause of outage, which compromised services from 911 emergency calls to payments processing and left swathes of Canadians without phone or internet service for much of Friday. Some have reportedly yet to see service restored.
The nationwide disruption, which the minister’s office earlier called “unacceptable,” has led some to question the level of concentration of services in the telecom sector and is also raising questions about the communications giant’s plan to merge with rival Shaw Communications Inc. in a blockbuster $26-billion deal that has already prompted a challenge from the Competition Bureau.
Maher Yaghi, a telecom analyst at Bank of Nova Scotia, said the immediate impact on Rogers will be a $65-million to $75-million cost to credit customers, and a likely loss of some customers who are frustrated by the second such outage in the past 18 months, but that increased regulatory scrutiny could also pose a risk going forward.
“Beyond the immediate financial impact, increased political and regulatory risk is a possibility,” the analyst said in a note to clients, adding that “arguments for increased competition (in the telecom space) to reduce future failure risk abound.”
Champagne was the first federal official to voice concerns about the concentration of services that would result from the merger of Rogers and Shaw, saying in March that the wholesale transfer of wireless assets to Rogers was “fundamentally incompatible” with the government’s objectives to increase mobile competition and lower prices.
Increased political and regulatory risk is a possibility
Richard Leblanc, a professor of governance, law and ethics at York University, said earlier in the day Monday that Champagne and Rogers chief executive Tony Staffieri should not be meeting behind closed doors, given the crucial services affected by the outage.
“Meetings should occur in public and ideally under oath like in the U.S.,” he said. “No doubt threat actors have witnessed what happened and how financial health care and emergency response can be impaired by a telecom outage.”
Leblanc proposed that telecoms should be restricted in the bundling of services and forced to lower barriers to switching services in the aftermath of the outage.
Yaghi, the Scotia analyst, said regulatory oversight needs to balance the risk of future failures against the increased costs of building parallel networks, including costs to consumers.
“History from other failures, in other parts of the world, shows that regulators have chosen to increase oversight rather than force a complete overhaul of the competitive landscape,” he told clients in his note.
The analyst maintained an 80 per cent probability on the merger going through, with Rogers and Shaw having struck a $2.85-billion agreement to sell Shaw’s Freedom mobile assets to Quebecor Inc. to alleviate competition concerns.
Yaghi noted that companies and governments have recovered from other massive service interruptions, including a system failure at Amazon that brought down the internet for many hours and was blamed on human error.
“System failures (due to human error, cyber or environmental disasters etc.) are painful to users and economies, however Amazon was able to identify the cause of the issue and put in place improvements to reduce the risk of future similar failures,” he wrote. “Reputational damage was transient and AWS currently sits as the market share leader in cloud services.”
Rogers to credit customers for massive outage, CEO says, as service returns
Quebecor wants to help Rogers and Shaw in battle against competition watchdog
Rogers, Shaw make deal to sell Freedom Mobile to Quebecor for $2.85B in hopes of getting merger approval
Competition Bureau’s case against Rogers-Shaw leaves some industry watchers scratching their heads
But Leblanc said the Rogers outage exposed shortcomings in crisis management and “came at a very inopportune time for the company,” which is still trying to recover its reputation from “family squabbles” that led to a board overhaul and court challenge over control last year.
He noted that the network failure occurred at 5 a.m., but the first communications about it did not come until about four hours later.
“There was limited reporting on the root cause and even that it was not a cyberattack by a foreign threat actor would be helpful and enable customers to plan,” Leblanc said.
“There is a path to recovery but it involves serious attention to corporate governance, crisis management, and robust and independently audited internal controls.”
Leblanc said authorities with oversight of telecommunications services also bear some of the responsibility for what transpired last week, and that there should be assurance by regulators that internal controls are in place for maintenance, software and other updates.
“There should be a public interest in telecoms,” he said.